The Tree That Had Nothing to Prove
The Tree That Had Nothing to Prove
From our friend Lindsey V. in the New York Center
Humility expresses itself in many ways: freedom from pride, an honest recognition of our limitations, the willingness to accept help, and an openness to learning from others. Yet there is a deeper, more fundamental aspect of humility that an old Taoist story, told by Zhuangzi, illustrates nicely.
A carpenter came upon an enormous tree. Its trunk was twisted, its branches crooked, and its wood so irregular that it was unsuitable for making furniture, boats, or houses. Finding no practical use for it, the carpenter dismissed it as worthless and continued on his way. That night, however, the tree appeared to him in a dream. The tree challenged the carpenter's judgment. Why should its worth be determined solely by its usefulness to human beings? Who was the carpenter to decide what made a tree valuable?
The carpenter had never considered that his own needs and expectations might limit what he was able to see. He had mistaken his narrow perspective for the measure of everything. This story appeals to me because it reveals how readily and unconsciously we judge everything, including ourselves, through the narrow frame of reference shaped by the experiences and conditioning of our lower centers. The carpenter saw the tree only in terms of its usefulness to him, never questioning how his own level of being limited what he could see. How often do we do the same?
We measure ourselves and others by artificial standards of accomplishment, intelligence, appearance, and social standing. We spend much of our lives accumulating possessions and trying to become somebody—someone important, admired, or special. I cringe now when I remember how much I once feared being just an ordinary human being, and how, in all my striving to be special, I overlooked the simple experience of being present. Our lower centers are so occupied with what we have and what we might become that we lose sight of the reality of what is here, now.
I think the sense of the complete unimportance of all one's personal life and personal psychology is the key to entry into relation [with higher worlds]. — Rodney Collin
Humility offers another possibility. It is the willingness to see ourselves and the world as they are, without the distortions of self-importance. It is neither self-deprecation nor a belief that we are worthless. Rather, selflessness grows out of humility. Gurdjieff's teaching on external considering offers a practical expression of humility. External considering means consciously taking into account another person's circumstances, needs, and point of view, rather than reacting mechanically from our own expectations and self-importance. It requires us to put ourselves in another person's place while remaining present.
Gurdjieff also taught that love is something we must learn through conscious effort, and he suggests beginning with plants and animals. As he said, "Whoever wishes to learn to love his neighbor must begin by trying to love plants and animals." By learning to care for other forms of life, we begin to move beyond our habitual likes, dislikes, and self-centered concerns, becoming more open and available to presence.
The carpenter in Zhuangzi's story saw only a useless tree because he judged it according to his own needs and standards. He failed to recognize its value apart from its usefulness to him. Humility softens such judgments and recognizes the limitations of our own perspective. In this way, external considering becomes humility in action, creating space for presence, compassion, and a more conscious relationship with all living things.
The tree did not need to prove its worth, apologize for its crooked branches, or become something else. (I notice how often I say “I’m sorry” throughout the day, even when there is nothing to apologize for.) It simply grew, providing a home for birds and squirrels, enriching the soil, and offering shade and beauty. Humility begins when we stop trying so hard to be somebody special. When we no longer need to be at the center of everything, there is finally room for something else: engaging presence.
They go hand in hand, this state [presence] and selflessness, humility and love – all three. — The Teacher
Bristlecone Pine, photograph by author





Comments