top of page

Space for Presence

Nov 5
3 min read

Space for Presence

From our friend Lindsey V. of the New York Centre

Unscrew the locks from the doors! Unscrew the doors themselves from their jambs! — Walt Whitman, Song of Myself

Recently, I was sharing some ideas from the Fourth Way and the teachings of my teacher with people who had newly embraced Catholicism. I was struck by how often they responded, “Oh, that's like this concept in Catholicism,” or “That's similar to that teaching.” Rather than hearing the ideas freshly, they seemed to be fitting everything into a framework they already knew. It reminded me of Ouspensky's observation that we tend to translate new ideas into familiar ones, often losing something essential in the process. Of course, we all do this. Our minds are crowded with opinions, expectations, memories, and associations, leaving little room for anything genuinely new to enter. When we are so occupied with what we already know, we are hardly present to what is before us. True spiritual work invites us to open our minds and hearts, allowing fresh impressions to enter. Even familiar teachings must be heard as though for the first time. Otherwise, our knowledge itself becomes another obstacle to awakening.

In the Fourth Way, Gurdjieff taught that our ordinary lives are largely mechanical, governed by habits and reactions. Through self-remembering and non-identification, we can create an inner space in which we can observe thoughts and emotions without becoming lost in them. This allows space for presence. The Tibetan Buddhist teacher Chögyam Trungpa Rinpoche spoke of the importance of the gap, a moment of openness between thoughts or habitual reactions. Yet silence and empty space can be surprisingly uncomfortable. Accustomed to the constant activity of our minds, we reach for our phones, retreat into imaginary dramas, or find something else to occupy us. A quote commonly attributed to Trungpa captures this fear of letting go:

The bad news is you're falling through the air, nothing to hang on to, no parachute. The good news is, there's no ground.

We cling to familiar reference points—our opinions, identities, and ways of understanding ourselves. When these begin to lose their hold, we may feel as though we are falling through empty space. Yet what initially feels like uncertainty and fear may become an experience of freedom and presence.

When I was younger, I really hated the experience of being new. Whether it was joining a group where I knew no one, teaching an unfamiliar subject, or learning a new skill, I found the uncertainty deeply uncomfortable. My false personality had constructed an image of myself as someone competent, knowledgeable, and in control. Being a beginner threatened that image and exposed a vulnerability I did not want to feel. Vulnerability is something I have spent a lifetime trying to avoid. Rather than experiencing the uncertainty directly, I would buffer it, finding ways to avoid the awkwardness of not knowing by sticking to a script. When we believe we already know, we close ourselves to new possibilities, often through fear of making mistakes. Being a beginner requires a certain courage: the willingness to remain open and receptive without the protection of our accumulated knowledge and assumptions.

In the beginner's mind there are many possibilities, but in the expert's there are few. — Shunryu Suzuki Roshi

I teach astronomy, and I am often astonished by some of the wild and unconventional answers my students, most of whom grew up in cities, give to questions that seem quite basic to me. My first reaction is sometimes to wonder how they could possibly think that way. But then I realize that I have lost some of the very spaciousness and curiosity I am trying to cultivate. I have become the expert who already knows the right answer. My knowledge, useful as it is, can prevent me from seeing the question freshly or appreciating the unexpected ways my students approach it. Their answers remind me how easily expertise can narrow our perspective and how important it is to remain curious even about things we think we understand. This is all the more true in the spiritual realm, where the conviction that we already know what awakening is can prevent us from receiving the very new experiences we are seeking.

Can we allow ourselves to be beginners again, without immediately reaching for familiar explanations or the security of knowing? Can we simply show up and see what the moment has to offer? Genuine spiritual practice requires the courage to be vulnerable, to live in that space with presence, without needing to fill it or define it.

Out beyond ideas of wrongdoing and rightdoing, there is a field. I'll meet you there. — Rumi


Kangchenjunga, Nicholas Roerich, 1924



Comments


bottom of page